#1
IP: 71.104.179.77
|
|||
|
|||
Compression Testing for a Newb
...Never done one. How is it done on an A4?
Looking to buy a Catalina 30 and the engine is acting up. Want to test compression among other things, but I figure if the compression is bad I'll just move on. Best compression tester for A4? Is it as simple as pulling the spark plug wire off the top of a cylinder and plugging the tester in then cranking? Any and all help would be much appreciated! |
#2
IP: 128.177.81.110
|
||||
|
||||
This old post may help you along the way:
Quote:
|
#3
IP: 24.152.131.153
|
||||
|
||||
If the boat is in the water it's absolutely critical the raw water intake remain closed during any cranking episodes without the engine running such as compression testing.
__________________
Neil 1977 Catalina 30 San Pedro, California prior boats 1987 Westsail 32, 1970 Catalina 22 Had my hands in a few others |
#4
IP: 199.173.225.33
|
||||
|
||||
IIRC, the spread from low to high is more important than the raw number.
|
#5
IP: 96.229.18.9
|
|||
|
|||
Take yur' time
JSR, first welcome the the Afourian MMI Forum. Pay good attention to the list Bill supplied and ask of what you do not understand!
First be sure the battery is full and all plugs are out for inspection and a pic would be nice too! Have the choke off and the throttle at wide open during testing!!!! Doing the compression check and anytime you cranking for anything keep the water closed as per Shawn. Now the numbers are not as important as being somewhat close to each other Do a compression test DRY first and record the numbers. After that squirt some oil (WD-40 OK) into the cylinders and check again. If the second set of numbers is higher that is normal, now we look for a consistent change in the numbers wet with oil. The split will tell us about the rings and the valves. If the engine is dead on one or more cylinder it is probably a stuck valve which in most cases is no biggie! BTW I bought my boat with the engine seized in 1984! It took 2 days to get it broke free and one exhaust valve replaced and she has run flawlessly since, that's over another 25 years. I was planning on dropping in a diesel with the deal I got but had to get the boat moved in a hurry so I tried to get it running "temporarily" and I spent the diesel money on liquid bread a far better choice! Dave Neptune |
#6
IP: 75.205.104.26
|
|||
|
|||
JSR Welcome, what do you mean when you say A4 is acting up? Hard starting? smoking? missing?
Dave, My experience is test the compression dry, if it test low squirt motor oil, not WD40 in the cylinders through the spark plug hole. Retest, if compression comes up it indicates a ring sealing problem. If the compression remains the same it indicates a valve leakage problem. Last edited by Carl-T705; 06-13-2013 at 10:46 AM. |
#7
IP: 24.145.113.187
|
||||
|
||||
JSR,
What exactly is the engine doing? A compression check is a great idea on any boat you might buy. But if you can tell how the engine is "acting up", the group here can probably give you other things to check and think about. Some issues can be readily resolved while others might be more work than they appear. Many times, a poorly running engine is returned to a well-running engine with something as simple as a new $11 condenser or a cleaning of the idle jet on the carb. The A-4 is a wonderful engine and depending on your access (which is pretty good in a C-30) is quite easy and forgiving to work on. Shoot some pictures and tell us a little about what the engine is doing. There are many extremely knowledgeable A-4 owners here that have helped me learn how to work on my A-4. I'm certain there are answers to all your questions and probably a lot of wisdom from which you can benefit as well. To answer your question: Quote:
HF Compression Test Kit To check compression, simply remove the spark plugs and screw in the adapter and crank (As Neil says, remember to close the Raw Water Intake seacock while doing this. This is important because most marine engines use a water lift exhaust system. The Water Lift system uses exhaust pressure to push cooling water out of the water lift up and through the exhaust system. Without the engine running, there is no exhaust pressure to push the water out. The water will eventually fill up the exhaust manifold and then the engine itself. Although not fatal to the engine, it is a real hassle to correct.) The gauge will hold the pressure until you release it. Bill's and Dave's advice about hot and cold compression tests, with and without oil, gives you more information. Also, a stuck valve on an A-4 that hasn't been run in while is not uncommon. These stuck valves are typically caused by humidity causing mischief on the valve stem. A stuck valve is very often fixed by adding some lubricant to the fuel to send oil through the combustion side of the engine along with soaking the affected cylinder in a good lubricant (most of us use Marvel Mystery Oil, i.e. "MMO"). Good luck and keep the forum updated on your progress and please ask questions!
__________________
Tom "Patina" 1977 Tartan 30 Repowered with MMI A-4 2008 |
#8
IP: 206.125.176.5
|
||||
|
||||
Mmmmmmmm...liquid bread!
Except it was Neil that commented about the raw water being closed. However, I will add further that the reason to do so is that the starter spinning the motor also spins the water pump..this pumps raw water in the exhaust, but if the engine is not running the exhaust gases cannot expel the accumulating water..so the water backs up the hot exhaust stack and dumps into the cylinders. Hence the reason to always close the raw water thru-hull if you can't get the motor running and are compression testing or otherwise troubleshooting. Once the engine is running, it is safe to open, as the exhaust gases can take the water up thru the wet exhaust system to the transom. On a C-30 the raw water intake should be directly adjacent to the engine, near the carb & fuel pump. JSR, several of us here have C-30's..great boats, I bet we can salvage the engine and you'll be fine. We'll be happy to help with whatever you decide.
__________________
-Shawn "Holiday" - '89 Alura 35 #109 "Twice Around" - '77 C-30, #511 with original A-4 & MMI manifold - SOLD! (no longer a two boat owner!!) |
#9
IP: 50.197.27.245
|
||||
|
||||
check oil too
another lesson i learned is to look for water in oil. oil w water will have a grey-brown milkshake appearance. i would think you can see by pulling dipstick, but the bigger the sample, the better. doesnt mean engine is toast, but could be a long series of headaches to find where water came from
|
#10
IP: 71.104.179.77
|
|||
|
|||
I belong to quite a few other forums, flying, hunting, fishing, etc and I have to say, I have never had such a kind/informative/helpful response to anything. To that I offer you all a virtual beer. And if you ever find yourself around San Pedro, Ca, you are more than welcome to trade that in for a real one.
The problem is this, the engine started, idled and ran fine. Up until around 50% throttle the thing seemed great. After the 50%, it would sputter and lose power. To which bringing it back down would revive it. I was thinking fuel starvation, perhaps in part by a dirty carb? Perhaps old fuel? Thoughts? I plan to take note of all the advice here and apply it on my next buyer's visit this weekend. Side note: Seller said engine was overhauled in the last 4 years and isn't sure what the problem is. More support to fuel issue? Again, thank you for the help gentlemen. I feel much more confident in pulling the trigger on this boat because of the support here! |
#11
IP: 24.152.131.153
|
||||
|
||||
San Pedro????
I'm in Cabrillo Marina, Berth 31, dock 'C'.
__________________
Neil 1977 Catalina 30 San Pedro, California prior boats 1987 Westsail 32, 1970 Catalina 22 Had my hands in a few others Last edited by ndutton; 06-14-2013 at 07:51 AM. |
#12
IP: 206.125.176.5
|
||||
|
||||
dirty main jet?
Quote:
JSR, that sounds like it could be a clogged main jet. The idle jet controls fuel mixture until appoximately 1,200 RPM, then the main jet takes over. Those throttle up symptoms could be some junk in the main jet. Is there any change in the behavior if you use the choke? There should be a horizontal bolt on the bottom of the carb bowl that provides access to the main jet. (be careful, don't lose the fiber washer..it is there because it is NOT a tapered thread!) - try removing that bolt (1/2" wrench) and flushing some fuel out of the fuel bowl into a clean container to see the condition of the fuel after it settles a bit. Ventilate very well until the fuel smell is gone and see how it goes. I am hoping a fuel bowl flush will dislodge any debris that may be clogging the jet. You may end up taking the carb apart, but this is a quick & dirty cross-your-fingers remedy I'd try first.
__________________
-Shawn "Holiday" - '89 Alura 35 #109 "Twice Around" - '77 C-30, #511 with original A-4 & MMI manifold - SOLD! (no longer a two boat owner!!) Last edited by sastanley; 06-14-2013 at 09:56 AM. |
#13
IP: 107.217.19.207
|
|||
|
|||
Personal story
JSR, About five years ago when I acquired my A4 powered Catalina 30, I bought it despite the "ugly duckling" engine, but now I wouldn't have it any other way. Mine was purchased in San Pedro and then "Motored" to Marina Del Rey and then on to it's present home in Oxnard. During that journey, thank's to our new "alcohol laced" fuel, I dislodged over 30 years of fuel system gunk. Since arriving at Oxnard I have changed out the fuel tank, fuel lines and filter and have had "zero" fuel system problems since. The Catalina 30 is an extremely "engine access" friendly design that makes engine service and repair far easier than in most other brands of the same general size. Before passing on this particular boat, my advice would be to talk to Neil. I'm betting that you will soon realize that this engine is the right choice for this size of sailboat.
Tom |
#14
IP: 24.145.113.187
|
||||
|
||||
Quote:
Quote:
Ethanol wreaks havoc on non-ethanol rated fuel systems. Since boats last a lot longer than cars, and we use them less frequently, the problems are magnified. E-85 fuel contains 15% ethanol. Ethanol (ethyl alcohol) is a poor fuel for our situations, but it is a very good solvent. As fuel varnish builds up in our old gasoline systems, ethanol, being the solvent that it is, breaks up the varnish and attacks non-alcohol rated fuel lines and gaskets in our fuel systems. This creates a lot of trash in the fuel system. Most of this is caught by filter systems, but occasionally, some varnish in the carb or from the fuel lines finds its way to the idle or main jets. The symptoms fit this very possible scenario. I'm also wondering about distributor advance, but if it were my boat, I'd clean the carb first (it probably needs it anyway) and maybe just pop the top on the distributor and check to see if the advance mechanism advances smoothly. Good luck and keep us posted.
__________________
Tom "Patina" 1977 Tartan 30 Repowered with MMI A-4 2008 |
#15
IP: 199.168.148.137
|
|||
|
|||
I Wouldn't Be So Presumptuous As To Speak For Neil......
But I have the feeling that for the price of a good lunch he would go look at the boat\engine with you.
Send him a PM and see where it goes. TRUE GRIT |
#16
IP: 107.217.19.207
|
|||
|
|||
"oops"
John, You are absolutely right that I should not have handed this project off to Neil without his permission, but I have a strange feeling that he will forgive me for doing it.
To elaborate a little more on TomG's comments about the effects of ethonal on these older fuel systems, after removing the original aluminum tank and cutting it open, I found that it was spotless except for the "leak causing corrosion" at it's lowest point. The clean aluminum was the result of the "solvent" effect of the alcohol. The debris downstream of the fuel tank in the filter, fuel pump and carb was another story. The older fuel lines were also showing signs of "swelling", another sign of the alcohol's effects. Tom |
#17
IP: 206.125.176.5
|
||||
|
||||
Tom, I did not cut my tank open, but I had the exact same symptoms in my original aluminum tank. A little varnish covered pinhole in the forward lowest point that sprung a leak when I 'wiped away' the varnish plug. I suspect the plug was formed by ethanol cleaning up the tank and the gunk depositing in the corrosion hole. The P.O. had not replaced fuel lines, etc. so that was something I had already done w/ Racor & Moyer polishing filter that winter. Turns out I also needed to replace the tank. That leak sprung 7 days before launch while the boat was on the hard with a full tank from winter storage.
I really like my poly Moeller tank.
__________________
-Shawn "Holiday" - '89 Alura 35 #109 "Twice Around" - '77 C-30, #511 with original A-4 & MMI manifold - SOLD! (no longer a two boat owner!!) Last edited by sastanley; 06-14-2013 at 12:21 PM. |
#18
IP: 172.10.154.138
|
|||
|
|||
"Actually"
Shawn, It was one of your posts from many moons ago that prompted me to do a "feel" check on the bottom corner of the tank. When my fingers came back with a brownish/orange stain, I knew that it was time for removal; the tank not my fingers. Subsequent inspection showed that the corrosion was limited to a small area where any water would settle. I also went with a Moeler tank.
Tom |
#19
IP: 24.152.131.153
|
||||
|
||||
My ears were burning
Yeah, these guys know I'm a cheap date . . . .
__________________
Neil 1977 Catalina 30 San Pedro, California prior boats 1987 Westsail 32, 1970 Catalina 22 Had my hands in a few others |
#20
IP: 71.104.179.77
|
|||
|
|||
PM sent to Neil. And my birthday is the same as Elvis'. Coincidence?
|
#21
IP: 174.237.6.97
|
||||
|
||||
Reviving compression test thread...
In another thread, I had a cooling concern and vinegar flushed, removed and tested thermostat and while it was out, vinegar flushed again. Everything is checking out fine EXCEPT...
Compression test checked out after warming up these numbers: 0/90/90/120. I did not have any MMO put the last in the fuel tank put motor oil in cylinder 1. I replaced the spark plugs. The engine seems to run fine altho still seems to "hunt" during idle but now what? Compression test again? Kinda bummed, in 2009 all numbers were 115 to 120.
__________________
Barbara L. Hickson Flight Risk C&C 33-1 Chas., SC |
#22
IP: 24.238.61.40
|
|||
|
|||
The compression test is telling you that a valve in cylinder #1 is stuck. Most likely, a bit of corrosion is keeping it open and if you can tap the valve down through the spark plug hole with an Allen wrench, it'll probably be fine after you run the engine for a few minutes and get the valve cleaned off. Less likely, but still possible, are a broken valve spring or bent valve. Lots of info on all these afflictions here.
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Valid Compression Test | jkenan | Troubleshooting | 11 | 12-18-2013 09:14 PM |
Another Low Compression Issue | Triton106 | Troubleshooting | 19 | 09-19-2011 09:27 AM |
Compression test and general questions | mpahl | Overhaul | 6 | 03-22-2011 02:20 PM |
High Compression? | Kurt | General Maintenance | 4 | 06-17-2008 03:42 PM |
Compression - Good enough, or Not | High Hopes | Overhaul | 2 | 06-06-2008 10:29 PM |