#26
IP: 174.94.19.168
|
||||
|
||||
I am constantly amazed at what some P/O's think is appropriate repair on a vessel.
Especially in an area of high stress - low tolerance fittings like a prop shaft and associated drive train. Wow! Caveat emptor... |
#27
IP: 206.125.176.5
|
||||
|
||||
toddster..I have no visual yet on what is going on here, as I cannot see any of your pics at work.
I know you don't want to hear this, but what started for me as a simple, "I am going to haul the boat for a week in early June, paint the bottom and change my prop", turned into 10 weeks on the hard replacing everything behind the A-4 output shaft, except for the prop strut, including a shaft log repair from years of misalignment. - so I feel your pain. At this point, I'd take a deep breath, take a step back and assess the whole situation, and then decide on how to proceed given your individual situation ($$, time, skills, etc.) Patience here..By the way, as soft as lead is, it will still hurt... So, Neil, as a matter of curiosity..how is a prop strut installed?? I am thinking about how they are built..a single cast piece right? Is it external with a backing plate on the inside & simply bolts thru?
__________________
-Shawn "Holiday" - '89 Alura 35 #109 "Twice Around" - '77 C-30, #511 with original A-4 & MMI manifold - SOLD! (no longer a two boat owner!!) Last edited by sastanley; 06-26-2012 at 10:02 AM. |
#28
IP: 71.54.207.52
|
|||
|
|||
At this point, it would not be that much bigger of a deal to replace the strut. I just have to let go of the idea of actually sailing this summer. It's a process.
This is already week 12 of the haul-out. I keep writing rent checks for an empty slip. The bottom needed a lot more work than I had counted on. I had to strip out every scrap of the (lethal) wiring and re-wire from scratch. (A few toys were added.) I didn't imagine that I would solve all of this boat's problems in one haul-out. But there end up being just too many that need to be addressed before it re-floats. As far as the strut construction - typically they are bolted through the hull then the inside part is embedded in resin to hold it immobile. Replacing them involves excavating the resin to locate the head of the strut, then re-pouring. (Oddly enough, most of the boats that I looked at buying needed a new strut.) Here's a detail from the Ericson manual: What's weird about this strut (other than its form) is that there is no such wedge on the inside. Well, there is a small wedge, but the log goes through it. The existing strut is bolted-through aft of the wedge. I'll need to investigate this more next weekend. To even see what's going on, I'll need to remove the batteries, the battery box, and finish stripping the bottom around the drive-line. Note that this "detail" is apparently just an example sketch ("Typical strut installation, E27 thru E36"), but it seems to show a radically different shaft angle. Last edited by toddster; 06-26-2012 at 01:55 PM. |
#29
IP: 97.120.52.184
|
|||
|
|||
Your A4
Hi Toddster
Loved the picture of your A4, especially since I have one just like it in PIECES in my garage. Questions: who made the fresh water add on? How did you mount the heat exchanger? Can you point me to some info on replacing the raw water cooled late model A4 in my Ericson 27 with the fresh water cooled version? Like, modifications to the existing raw water intake/exhaust? And, what works well for getting the old engine out and the new one on board? Can I use the boom and a block and tackle? I love the Ericson 27 because of the great engine access, and I'm thrilled to find the forum. Have had the sailboat awhile now, but am just now finding all of you. Thanks in advance Veronica |
#30
IP: 107.0.6.242
|
||||
|
||||
I think we may be getting a little wrapped around the er, driveshaft here. In your situation I would check to see that your shaft log will pass a new 1" shaft. If it will I would simply get one made up for the new prop, put a new cutless bearing in your cobblestrut, align as best you can, and go sailing. Next winter on the hard have another look at it.
|
#31
IP: 71.54.207.52
|
|||
|
|||
Er... how did we get on to a 1" shaft? The new prop and bearing are for a 3/4" shaft. I think the OLD prop was made for a 7/8 or 1" and was retrofitted with a tapered sleeve to fit on the old straight (non-tapered) 3/4" shaft.
Short-term options are to buy a new shaft to fit the new prop, or put the old prop and old (worn) shaft back on. If I buy a new shaft, I need to first decide whether to do something about the strut. And then bet back to the engine maintenance |
#32
IP: 206.125.176.5
|
||||
|
||||
toddster - Since I am 'in-the-dark' so to speak & cannot see your pics, maybe a little review of where you are at will help me..please correct any errors.
suggestions & questions I have: A new custom shaft with the correct taper (and length) is ~$175 (this was my 2009 cost). Strut cost - unknown stuffing box = ~$75 couplers = ~$40-60 fit & face coupler to shaft..~$100 Something must be done with the current shaft to fit the new prop..may be cheaper than a new shaft, but the issue with length remains the same.. Cannot see the cobble-strut, can't comment on it yet. What is the condition of shaft log & stuffing box? The new prop will not decay if it is not used. Since you are able to make good observations now, perhaps a "wish list" for the next haul as Hanley recommended. Take notes now, so a proper parts list (shaft log ID & OD, new shaft/strut/couplers, etc. if necessary), can be assembled while you are sailing. I know this is a pain, and we aren't writing the checks.
__________________
-Shawn "Holiday" - '89 Alura 35 #109 "Twice Around" - '77 C-30, #511 with original A-4 & MMI manifold - SOLD! (no longer a two boat owner!!) Last edited by sastanley; 06-26-2012 at 02:54 PM. |
#33
IP: 71.54.207.52
|
|||
|
|||
Will have to remove the battery box to get a better look at the log and stuffing box. It hasn't been a problem - the rubber hose part just looks old and has only single hose clamps at each end. I did not see a drop of water come through the packing nut last year.
|
#34
IP: 206.125.176.5
|
||||
|
||||
toddster...Understand..my situation just got worse the farther I dug into it, so I ripped out & replaced everything...however, my issue started with a leaky stuffing box..If the nut & packing are in serviceable condition, you can get just a new hose..I would add a hose clamp on each end if there is enough material underneath to grab onto.
Don't you just love all the suggestions from the guys that don't have to climb in there and do the work?!?!?!?
__________________
-Shawn "Holiday" - '89 Alura 35 #109 "Twice Around" - '77 C-30, #511 with original A-4 & MMI manifold - SOLD! (no longer a two boat owner!!) |
#35
IP: 107.0.6.242
|
||||
|
||||
Quote:
|
#36
IP: 184.6.139.91
|
||||
|
||||
Bump
Quote:
BUMP... Anybody see Veronica's message? Sorry Todd. I know you've got some big fish to fry. And, Veronica... welcome!
__________________
-Jerry 'Lone Ranger' 1978 RANGER 30 |
#37
IP: 71.54.207.52
|
|||
|
|||
Hi Veronica. I had another long thread last year just about the FWC (maybe it was in somebody else's thread - can't find it off hand). Someone posted a photo of at least one other 70's ericson with the exact same set-up. But I'm sure it was done back in the 70's and the supplier is long gone. You could roll your own by purchasing an extra water pump and a heat exchanger - I think the company that made mine is still around. Or you can buy bolt-on kits already made for the A4, either here at Moyer Marine or at Indigo Electronics.
My heat exchanger is just hanging on by one stud on the engine, and it rattles against the galley, sticks up above the stock engine cover height, and blocks access to the carb. While I'm cleaning up the engine compartment, I'm going to move it to the starboard bulkhead, where there's more room. It's just a matter of routing hoses. Although you might consider different options, if you are planning to install other related accessories, like a water heater or a cabin heater that run off the engine coolant. I'm sure that both the Moyer and Indigo solutions work great. My only advice would be to select a raw-water pump that uses the same impeller as your old water pump (which becomes the recirculating pump.) Just to cut down on the number of different tools and spares you need to keep on hand. Mine has one Sherwood pump and one Oberdorfer, with different impellers. And the oberdorfer requires a pair of snap-ring pliers to change out. Of course, if one fails, in a pinch, you can just switch back to raw water cooling by swapping hoses around. Last edited by toddster; 06-26-2012 at 08:27 PM. |
#38
IP: 173.166.26.241
|
||||
|
||||
How's this for a working theory? The original strut which was aft of the present cobblestrut got whacked and maybe weakened the hull. The PO decided to abandon the original and go forward where he cobbled the new strut somewhat shorter than the original so as to maintain the correct angle. The original shaft was left in place. Two things: check the hull for signs of a repair aft of the present strut and check the shaft for signs of a different cutless wear position.
|
#39
IP: 206.125.176.5
|
||||
|
||||
Hanley, Sounds exactly like something the P.O. of my boat would have done..
__________________
-Shawn "Holiday" - '89 Alura 35 #109 "Twice Around" - '77 C-30, #511 with original A-4 & MMI manifold - SOLD! (no longer a two boat owner!!) |
#40
IP: 71.54.207.52
|
|||
|
|||
No, the original gelcoat is undisturbed except exactly where the strut is. The new strut was never "filled and faired" possibly because they weren't sure it was going to work! I doubt that this was the original shaft - whatever took out the strut probably took out the shaft and prop too. From pictures I've seen, the original strut might have swept back at a steeper angle.
This strut seems solid enough and though it is probably a shop-built one-off, it is not so unlike other "adjustable struts" on the market (e.g. Buck Algonquin), apart from lack of streamlining. Unless there are gross alignment problems when the new parts arrive, I don't propose to do anything to it at this time. I'm going to dummy the prop up with a dowel and check clearances carefully, but probably I'll get a new shaft that's 1.5" or 2" shorter. BTW: other old Ericson owners tell me that the original struts tend to "work loose" with age because whatever was used to bed them inside the hull deteriorates with time. In those cases, they usually need to be re-installed, not replaced. |
#41
IP: 97.120.52.184
|
|||
|
|||
Thanks for replying
[QUOTE=toddster;55751]Hi Veronica. I had another long thread last year just about the FWC (maybe it was in somebody else's thread - can't find it off hand). Someone posted a photo of at least one other 70's ericson with the exact same set-up. But I'm sure it was done back in the 70's and the supplier is long gone. You could roll your own by purchasing an extra water pump and a heat exchanger - I think the company that made mine is still around. Or you can buy bolt-on kits already made for the A4, either here at Moyer Marine or at Indigo Electronics.
I'll do some searching for that thread. I've got all the parts, and am planning to re-assemble the engine with the heat exchanger and pump that came with it. The oberdorfer is still on the engine (that's good - I have experience with those already). But I would like a little confirmation on hoses required and the correct routing of the water - if you say that it's easy to switch back to raw water cooling, that gives me a clue. ANYWAY - if you or anyone comes up with that old thread, let me know! I just checked the heat exchanger and it was made by San Juan Engineering in Bellingham, WA. So, I'll google them and see if I turn anything up. Thanks - and if anyone can point me to a thread about switching out engines (using boom & block & tackle?) let me know. Veronica |
#42
IP: 24.152.131.155
|
||||
|
||||
Quote:
__________________
Neil 1977 Catalina 30 San Pedro, California prior boats 1987 Westsail 32, 1970 Catalina 22 Had my hands in a few others |
#43
IP: 71.54.207.52
|
|||
|
|||
Oh, well you could download the installation instructions from Indigo and crib from those. Or at least from the block diagrams at the end for hose connections. But we don't know how your raw water pump will be attached/driven.
As for hoisting with the boom - many have done it, though no manufacturer will say that it's safe. I think a key point is that there will be a lot of stress on the boom if you suspend it by a halyard clipped to the end then hoist a large weight in the middle. It would be safer to run the halyard from the same point at which the weight is suspended. That is, the halyard should bear the weight, not the boom. |
#44
IP: 108.4.61.32
|
||||
|
||||
Quote:
What started for me as "I'm going to haul the boat to pull the engine and do a quick tear-down and rebuild and have it back in the water in three months" turned into 13 months on the hard, which included not only the engine removal and rebuild, but also tearing out the cabin sole, fabricating from scratch a new bulkhead for the engine box, stripping and painting the entire bilge, building and installing a new battery box, replacing the centerboard pennant and pipe for the pennant, replacing all engine wiring, a few new gauges, new custom-made sail, new custom-made bimini and dodger, rebedding a couple portlights, removing some old abandoned through-hulls and glassing over the holes, removing and replacing the raw-water through-hull, repacking the stuffing box and replacing the stuffing box hose, replacing the prop with an Indigo, rebuilding the hot section of the exhaust, and I'm sure I'm forgetting something else. Still have a lot of work to do in that cabin... and on deck... and...
__________________
- Bill T. - Richmond, VA Relentless pursuer of lost causes |
#45
IP: 108.4.61.32
|
||||
|
||||
I hate this expression, but I totally feel your pain.
I paid for a full year in advance on my slip (because the owner gave me a 10% discount if I would pay for the year in advance) in September of 2010. I hauled the boat in January 2011. It was on the hard for the next full year. So I paid for a full year and used the slip only for 3 months. When September 2011 rolled around, I paid again, because it is such a great slip, I didn't want to lose it. The boat didn't go back in the water until February. So again, I paid for a full year, but missed the first four months. The marina owner is a really good guy - he said "If I knew you were going to be out that long, I would have talked to you about subletting the slip and we could have split the proceeds." Yup. I had that same thought - but I just didn't know how long it was going to be on the hard. Ah, what the hell, it's only money.
__________________
- Bill T. - Richmond, VA Relentless pursuer of lost causes |
#46
IP: 97.120.52.184
|
|||
|
|||
Thanks
Quote:
VM |
#47
IP: 216.115.121.240
|
||||
|
||||
hi!
Veronica,
I pulled my engine with the main boom. The key here is to be safe of course. I hooked up both(For safety) halyards back to a point on the boom at just where I lashed up the block gear to hoist the engine. The engine weighs ~320 lbs, so you don't want to drop it on your toes. The gel coat gets scratched up too if you don't watch it. I have Fresh-water cooling. Make sure like the others say to install any new gear in the engine room with due consideration to having to work around it when you have to fix some deep problem. I relocated my heat exchanger away from the engine. and made good access for maintaining it. I like to sit and stare at the engine compartment for a few beverages to imagine all the configurations I can. Quality time Welcome, Russ
__________________
Whiskeyjack a '68 Columbia 36 rebuilt A-4 with 2:1 "Since when is napping doing nothing?" |
#48
IP: 97.92.209.25
|
||||
|
||||
Quote:
Jeff.
__________________
With Powerboats, it's about the destination. With Sailboats, you are already there. Jeff S/V Karinya 1973 Grampian 30', Full Keel, A4 aux. |
#49
IP: 97.92.209.25
|
||||
|
||||
Quote:
Goal Setting and Keeping your eye on the prize,, Accounts for a lot of success in the boating world,,,, is what I Have Found.. and Other Thing in Life.
__________________
With Powerboats, it's about the destination. With Sailboats, you are already there. Jeff S/V Karinya 1973 Grampian 30', Full Keel, A4 aux. |
#50
IP: 71.54.207.52
|
|||
|
|||
Through-Hull Size?
Where were we? Oh yeah, still waiting for the new prop shaft to arrive. So I popped off the old gate-valve seacocks in order to replace them with modern stuff and opened up a whole new can of worms.
The intake through-hulls on my boat are 1/2-inch fittings (ID = 1/4-inch) and the drains are 1 1/4-inch. Nobody makes parts compatible with the 1/2-inch through-hulls any more, so one way to go is to get new 3/4" fittings (which will require glass work, since they won't fit into the old countersunk holes.) Anyway, the A4-specific question is, are these old 1/4-inch ID fittings in any way inadequate for cooling water flow? They have worked for 40 years... Just wondering if this could be a factor in the decision tree. |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Pictures of your Ericson 27 or E29 | Jason C | Ericson | 8 | 04-20-2010 05:35 PM |
27' ericson | pcb don | Exhaust System | 1 | 11-18-2009 03:07 PM |
Ericson 29: Sooty spark plugs | learking | Troubleshooting | 2 | 03-28-2008 05:23 PM |
1974 Ericson 27 | mwentling | Ericson | 2 | 03-28-2008 12:44 PM |
1974 Ericson 27 | mwentling | Drive Train / Propellers | 0 | 03-28-2008 10:57 AM |