#1
IP: 216.9.107.21
|
||||
|
||||
Camshaft During Engine Overhaul. Refurbish? Replace? Repent? Retreat?
Hi all,
Some of the many helpful frequent contributors may recognize I have an ongoing absurdly longwinded rebuild thread (just like the rebuild itself) but I wanted to pose this question separately since it's fairly specific. About 2.6 seconds after I got off the phone with Ken last week ordering every single moving part the Atomic 4 possesses, I realized we hadn't discussed the camshaft. In other contributors' rebuild threads, the only consideration I had seen regarding the camshaft was the relatively "soft" brass(?) camshaft bearings that could be damaged by "hot tanking" the block or careless reinstallation of the cam. In absence of any clear direction I took my camshaft up to the machine shop who's doing the block work. The shop owner took a look at the cam and cautiously advised I send the cam off to get "cleaned up" and "hardened" and provided the contact info to a company in Oklahoma. (I'm rebuilding the engine at home in Denver even though the boat is in San Francisco) He expressed concern over the surface rust on the cam lobes and hypothesized it would only cost around $65-ish for the necessary work. Understandably, I echo his sentiment that "you've spent this much money/time/effort on this project you might as well leave no stone unturned." My question is twofold. First, based upon these pictures would y'all be comfortable reinstalling this camshaft in a fresh rebuild? Second, does anyone know what "rebuilding" a camshaft involves? What does a 'hardening' process involve? Assumably if any material was machined off the camshaft, like a crankshaft, would likely need to be replaced with weld and polishing? What about the lobes? How would they assure the profile remained unchanged? Before someone suggests it, I'll point out that yes, I know our great host sells used camshafts for $125 and that's obviously an option. Frankly my only hesitation is that even the picture in the MMI catalogue appears to have some surface wear on the lobes as well. Moreover I'm just interested in whatever wisdom the braintrust has to offer on camshafts, hardening, tappets, best practices, etc.
__________________
Jonathan 1979 Catalina 30 #1497 An old Airline Pilot proverb: "If we don't help each other nobody else will." |
#2
IP: 216.9.107.21
|
||||
|
||||
And if anyone is interested enough, here is the contact that was recommended to me by my machine shop:
http://willhoitescams.tripod.com (Obviously not an endorsement since I haven't even contacted them yet but in case someone was curious as to who was recommended.)
__________________
Jonathan 1979 Catalina 30 #1497 An old Airline Pilot proverb: "If we don't help each other nobody else will." |
#3
IP: 12.230.196.198
|
|||
|
|||
HI McQ
I always enjoy reading your posts but now i am confused. Please fill us in on your story. I thought you rebuilt this engine a long time ago and are just now telling your story in a very interesting narrative. What is the real scoop? Are you currently rebuilding your engine or was it done a while ago. If so where are you at currently and when did the historical narrative stop?
__________________
Jim Zeller 1982 Catalina 30 Kelleys Island, Ohio |
#4
IP: 40.132.224.194
|
||||
|
||||
Hi Jim,
Yeah sorry for the confusion. I know it's generally frowned upon to have multiple threads going for the same engine rebuild but I was trying to avoid confusion since I'm not up to date with my 'rebuild thread' posts. I know I've been a little behind but I'll catch up I promise. To clarify the timeline, I purchased the boat with the non-running A-4 in 2013, tinkered with every engine system from 2013-2015 to diagnose the non-running condition (where my 'rebuild thread' narrative is currently stalled), ultimately got the engine running, then made a couple of significant screw-ups that likely caused enough damage to require the full rebuild, and now am currently in the middle of a slow-but-steady full teardown/rebuild (Oct 2018.) I didn't want to ruin the timeline and quickly skip through the story of how I toasted my engine just to catch up to present-day. It's informative and hopefully entertaining enough to be worth the wait. -Jonathan P.S. I hope the A-4ians will forgive my infrequency of posts for the time being. However, if anyone wants a taste of what it's like being in the throws of an ongoing multi-year whole-house renovation while dealing with a crying, screaming, sleepless, teething 13 month old who uses your nose as a chew toy, living in a semi-finished construction zone with 1 functional toilet, sleeping on an air mattress on the floor, covering 2 mortgages and full-time daycare, er, I mean 3 mortgages, supporting a stressed-out, sleep-deprived wife, and then commuting 997 miles to work at a job with a company that's in the middle of a merger, while trying to squeeze in 1 hour/month to work on your old busted sailboat motor, I can post a video on YouTube so you can get a better feel for the audio. Believe me the sound is worse than any rod knock you've ever heard!
__________________
Jonathan 1979 Catalina 30 #1497 An old Airline Pilot proverb: "If we don't help each other nobody else will." |
#5
IP: 107.77.97.120
|
||||
|
||||
It's kinda hard to tell, but I think you have a little surface rust on the base circle in the last snapshot. Probably from off-season storage.
Not a biggie. Take it to a machine shop and have them lightly polish it. Sometimes they call it "micro polishing". It looks like the bearings could use that love too. It's the same grit belt they use to do the final polish on a crank after it's been ground or just handled poorly by mechanic. A polishing belt is best after it's broken in. New ones take too much. Re: cam grinding, When an old cam(a core) is ground, the base circle is ground too. The lift remains the same. Or , if you are modifying it like a hot rod, some changes are made in the new profile. I think they may flame harden after this(?) A regrind probably costs more than a good used cam from MMI. I have even installed cams without polishing them in a few old timers—it's a judgement call. Rock on, Russ
__________________
Whiskeyjack a '68 Columbia 36 rebuilt A-4 with 2:1 "Since when is napping doing nothing?" Last edited by lat 64; 10-30-2018 at 12:20 PM. |
#6
IP: 137.200.32.54
|
||||
|
||||
So how about a hot cam?
|
#7
IP: 24.152.132.140
|
||||
|
||||
When evaluating this have a critical look at the lifter surfaces in contact with the cam. Decades ago I rebuilt a Ford 390 that included a new camshaft. I learned there would be no warranty unless a full set of new lifters were included on the same invoice.
__________________
Neil 1977 Catalina 30 San Pedro, California prior boats 1987 Westsail 32, 1970 Catalina 22 Had my hands in a few others |
The Following User Says Thank You to ndutton For This Useful Post: | ||
Dave Neptune (10-31-2018) |
#8
IP: 12.227.89.3
|
||||
|
||||
Thanks for the responses guys as always. I spoke with the camshaft shop in Oklahoma and I'm leaning towards having them grind it and send it back. Of course I'd always prefer to give the business to Moyer but in this case it sounds like I'll save money, reuse and original part, and they would be able to "clean up" the lifters as well if I send them as a group. Honestly I'm also a little curious to see how polished they can get it. Heres some pics of the lifters cylinders 1-4, in order from left to right.
Cylinder 1 Cylinder 2 Cylinder 3 Cylinder 4
__________________
Jonathan 1979 Catalina 30 #1497 An old Airline Pilot proverb: "If we don't help each other nobody else will." Last edited by Launchpad McQ; 11-01-2018 at 11:28 AM. Reason: Typo |
#9
IP: 104.13.213.227
|
|||
|
|||
The surface rust that your photos show will cause the lobe to go soft. Cams are usually nitrided after a grind. That is a high temperature soak in a nitrogen enriched environment.(there is more to it) . Nitriding hardens the surface for more wear resistance. Surface rust goes thru the nitriding and will allow much faster wear on the lobes. Make sure they do the lifters also because a rough surface on a lifter can eat a camshaft very quickly. Good luck. Grant.
|
The Following User Says Thank You to Grant For This Useful Post: | ||
Launchpad McQ (11-02-2018) |
#10
IP: 107.77.97.120
|
||||
|
||||
Quote:
But, On old flatheads and oddball motors we often set them right back in if they looked good. It was always a judgement call on those—cost verses life expectancy. On my A-4 I reground the mating surface. It is a similar job to grinding the tip of a valve stem. That's probably what McQ's Oklahoma shop means by "clean up" Grant, Yea, nitridng must be what I meant when I said "flame hardening". We never had the facilities up here for that so I never saw it. I just recall the nice newish gray surface on reground cams from mail-order suppliers.
__________________
Whiskeyjack a '68 Columbia 36 rebuilt A-4 with 2:1 "Since when is napping doing nothing?" Last edited by lat 64; 11-02-2018 at 01:27 PM. |
#11
IP: 107.77.97.120
|
||||
|
||||
No.
We aim for dependability, longevity, and economy. Now go clean the chalkboard and reflect these goals.
__________________
Whiskeyjack a '68 Columbia 36 rebuilt A-4 with 2:1 "Since when is napping doing nothing?" |
#12
IP: 67.176.27.175
|
||||
|
||||
I sent the cam to Oklahoma today. It's only $20 round trip shipping and I want to keep this project moving along when at all possible. The shop owner sounded like a good 'ol boy if I've ever heard one:
Me: "Yes, hello. My name is Jonathan and you were referred to me by Terry in Denver. I wanted to discuss if you'd be able to refurbish an old marine engine flat head cam on a-" "Yeeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaah! buuuuudy! you know I ain't dun' gone seen a cam I can fix yet!" Me: "Great, but this is from a more obscure small four cylinder engine that most machine shops in the midwest don't probably-" "Yeeeeeeeeeaaaaaah! buuuuuuudddy! Don't chu' go gone worryin' 'bout dat now you know I seen every cam from a Cushman lil' putt-putt to a 1000 hp Mustang ya hear!?" I'll report back in a week or so with pictures of how it goes...
__________________
Jonathan 1979 Catalina 30 #1497 An old Airline Pilot proverb: "If we don't help each other nobody else will." |
The Following User Says Thank You to Launchpad McQ For This Useful Post: | ||
sastanley (11-04-2018) |
#13
IP: 72.69.36.126
|
|||
|
|||
My town still uses Cushman "lil putt-putts" to collect trash twice a week, so I know exactly what you/he are talking about. Very distinctive three-wheeled utility vehicles.
|
#14
IP: 107.77.97.93
|
||||
|
||||
You forgot to ask what's the name of his dog.
Probably a one-eyed lab-mix that sleeps all day on a stinky blanket by the door. Sounds like a good shop. r.
__________________
Whiskeyjack a '68 Columbia 36 rebuilt A-4 with 2:1 "Since when is napping doing nothing?" |
The Following User Says Thank You to lat 64 For This Useful Post: | ||
sastanley (11-04-2018) |
#15
IP: 138.207.175.58
|
||||
|
||||
Who was it that originally mentioned the shop with the one-eyed dog? I read every single post, but after a hundred thousand or so, it gets a little foggy on the details.
Bill |
#16
IP: 24.152.132.140
|
||||
|
||||
Looks like it was Lat64 Russ
http://www.moyermarineforum.com/foru...67&postcount=7
__________________
Neil 1977 Catalina 30 San Pedro, California prior boats 1987 Westsail 32, 1970 Catalina 22 Had my hands in a few others Last edited by ndutton; 11-04-2018 at 06:18 PM. |
The Following User Says Thank You to ndutton For This Useful Post: | ||
sastanley (11-04-2018) |
#17
IP: 138.207.175.58
|
||||
|
||||
Yep, that's our guy!
Classic, and I LOVE this forum. Bill |
The Following User Says Thank You to Administrator For This Useful Post: | ||
sastanley (11-04-2018) |
#18
IP: 74.107.30.248
|
||||
|
||||
The "thanks" was not available when Russ wrote that back in 2009. I am glad it is now..thanks for finding that gem, Neil!!
__________________
-Shawn "Holiday" - '89 Alura 35 #109 "Twice Around" - '77 C-30, #511 with original A-4 & MMI manifold - SOLD! (no longer a two boat owner!!) |
#19
IP: 24.152.132.140
|
||||
|
||||
I typed "Mennonite" in the forum search function, it turned up that thread. Reading a few posts led me to Russ.
__________________
Neil 1977 Catalina 30 San Pedro, California prior boats 1987 Westsail 32, 1970 Catalina 22 Had my hands in a few others |
#20
IP: 74.107.30.248
|
||||
|
||||
The local Mennonites in my area have rebuilt for me two A-4 alternators, one starter, one Jeep starter, and our sailing club takes our 2 ton dinghy hoist motors to them every year for maintenance. They know their stuff. I distinctly remember in about 2011 taking my new to me alt into their shop and the guy at the counter recognized the Atomic 4 bronze paint and said, "this looks like it is from an Atomic 4", and I knew I was in good hands...They did not have the one-eyed dog, but they love Jesus..and advertise it well. no problem with any of that if that is what you are into!
__________________
-Shawn "Holiday" - '89 Alura 35 #109 "Twice Around" - '77 C-30, #511 with original A-4 & MMI manifold - SOLD! (no longer a two boat owner!!) Last edited by sastanley; 11-04-2018 at 09:23 PM. |
#21
IP: 8.40.215.126
|
||||
|
||||
Reminds me of when I needed my A4 crankshaft ground. I went to the shop "everyone goes to" first, sparkly place with great customer service and spotless shop coats. I found out they didn't actually have the equipment there to grind crankshafts, they sent them to another shop to have the work done.
I was able to get the name of that other shop so I went there. Older, out of the way place, no front desk, parts laying around all over the place, and finally I found an old guy in a greasy shop coat and talked to him. He said "yeah, we used to grind crankshafts, but we couldn't afford to keep the expensive machinery going, so we send 'em out for grinding". I found out where he sent the crankshafts. Holy crap, you should see this place! It's next to the homeless shelter in the worse part of town, no signage, old run down buildings, stacks of parts all over the place, and nonexistent to downright rude customer service. But sure enough, they had the one and only crank grinding machine in the area. Turns out crankshafts from pretty much every shop in the Puget Sound area go through them as they're the only ones with the machinery and skill to do it. they did a great job on my crank and I had them do the works to the block as well, all at reasonable prices. I'm guessing if I had just gone through the first sparkly clean shop with smiling customer service I would have paid much more, considering there would have been a few markups along the way before the crank found it's way to the grinder.
__________________
"A ship in the harbor is safe ... but that's not what ships are built for. |
#22
IP: 67.176.27.175
|
||||
|
||||
Well this just became a lot more trouble. I shipped the cam last Friday from a UPS store then called the machine shop owner Wednesday to see if he'd received it yet:
Him: "Noooooo siiiiiiiiir I don't reckon we seeeeen it yet." Me: Huh, well I'll call you Friday when I get home. Today... Him: "Nooooo siiiiiiiir we still ain't seeeeen it" I shipped it in a re-used Amazon box so I figured "Here we go again; some lowlife played Amazon roulette hoping to score a pair of Bose headphones and opened up the box to find a rusty cam and lifters." 15 minutes on the phone with UPS later we figured it out. The UPS store printed the wrong address on the shipping label and it got delivered to someone in Oklahoma City who undoubtedly right now has absolutely no idea what just showed up on their doorstep. Will UPS tell me what address that is? No way. I called the shop owner to tell him what happened and in true good ol' boy fashion he said "Weeeeeell hell! If it's in Oklahoma City just tell me where and I'll go scoop up it fer' ya' and take care of it." If only UPS were so customer oriented. They're going to send the driver out to the incorrect address on Monday, hopefully pick it up and ship it back to Denver, then I'll have to ship it back to OK when (if) I receive it. Wish me luck. P.S. Where's the emoji with red mad face, steam rising from the forehead, and lots of %$# type profanity? I need that one right now. Ring! Ring! "Uh Ken, do y'all still have a cam, timing gear, and 8 lifters kicking around."
__________________
Jonathan 1979 Catalina 30 #1497 An old Airline Pilot proverb: "If we don't help each other nobody else will." |
#23
IP: 74.107.30.156
|
||||
|
||||
Jonathon, ugh, sorry..nice of the shop to offer to retrieve the part.
__________________
-Shawn "Holiday" - '89 Alura 35 #109 "Twice Around" - '77 C-30, #511 with original A-4 & MMI manifold - SOLD! (no longer a two boat owner!!) |
#24
IP: 107.77.97.120
|
||||
|
||||
Jonathon,
Don't you have a tracking number? I wonder if the wrong address would show up on the UPS website when you track the package. My sympathies. Oh well, it's winter, not much sailing anyway eh?
__________________
Whiskeyjack a '68 Columbia 36 rebuilt A-4 with 2:1 "Since when is napping doing nothing?" |
#25
IP: 67.176.27.175
|
||||
|
||||
You'd think huh? I never really looked at the receipt but UPS doesn't print the destination address on there nor is it retrievable on the website using the tracking number. I guess I'll find out today whether or not they tracked it down. Fingers crossed.
__________________
Jonathan 1979 Catalina 30 #1497 An old Airline Pilot proverb: "If we don't help each other nobody else will." |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Engine Sputters and Coughs, and Needed Choke to Run Smooth | CaptainChas | Troubleshooting | 9 | 06-30-2009 10:50 PM |
Removing the engine from your boat | Don Moyer | General Interest | 13 | 06-27-2008 11:06 AM |
Overheating problems | jdaly986 | Cooling System | 1 | 01-16-2008 10:32 AM |
Replace it? Overhaul it? Overhaul it! | Motor John | Overhaul | 0 | 08-15-2006 01:41 AM |
Removing the engine from your boat | Don Moyer | Ranger | 7 | 12-12-2005 12:24 PM |