Oh yeah, I'm extremely familiar with The List of Craig. I just don't think this item will sell too well around here. I've never seen a prop like this on CL. Most people on CL are looking for an absolute, rock-bottom, dirt-cheap bargain.
The primary advantage of eBay is that you're reaching a vastly larger audience, and potentially connecting with someone out there who is looking for exactly this item.
I'll report back when/if the thing sells...